Play
Multi-Player
Coins
Community
Settings
Help
Community   Maps   Forum   Mail   Ladders   Clans   Recent Games
Sign In | Sign Up
<< Back to Off-topic Forum   

Posts 1 - 30 of 35   1  2  Next >>   
Punishment for desertion.: 6/23/2016 03:33:14


Paugers
Level 41
Report
What should be the punishment for deserting in the military? I think death, it's harsh but would get the message across that you should NEVER betray your nation and the men who are fighting with you in battle.
Punishment for desertion.: 6/23/2016 03:34:27


Radical Traditionalist
Level 30
Report
torture to death.
Punishment for desertion.: 6/23/2016 03:35:14


Cata Cauda 
Level 57
Report
Imprisonment.
Punishment for desertion.: 6/23/2016 03:50:40


Жұқтыру
Level 55
Report
A congratulation for being moral enough to not help killing innocent folk. War is very rarely justified (on either side - just capitulate if declared war upon), and I can't think of a justified war in the last 100 years.

Edited 6/23/2016 03:50:58
Punishment for desertion.: 6/23/2016 03:56:32


Paugers
Level 41
Report
^
It wasn't justified for America to declare war on Japan for bombing Pearl Harbor?
Punishment for desertion.: 6/23/2016 03:57:28


Cata Cauda 
Level 57
Report
^
It wasnt justified to bomb the ones that supply the enemies of Japan's allies?
Punishment for desertion.: 6/23/2016 03:59:00


Paugers
Level 41
Report
I'd say that was justified, you have to destroy the source...
Punishment for desertion.: 6/23/2016 04:01:13


GeneralPE
Level 56
Report
Total war saves lives. gtfo you pacifists; war encourages innovation.

Back to topic: Death. No question.
Punishment for desertion.: 6/23/2016 04:02:52


Paugers
Level 41
Report
^
+1

You threaten the lives of your fellow soldiers when you desert, it is the ultimate form of treason in my opinion, even above leaking information.
Punishment for desertion.: 6/23/2016 04:11:41


Zephyrum 
Level 60
Report
Nobody should be forced to work on the military to begin with.

If drafting was not forced, whatever punishment you come up doesn't matter. They know what they signed up for. But when some (or all) people are obliged to do it, then no punishment can be applied for having free will.

In fact, I encourage friendly fire in case you were force-brought into a war. There is no treason if your nation wasn't in your side to begin with...
Punishment for desertion.: 6/23/2016 04:16:17


Radical Traditionalist
Level 30
Report
Why live within a country you're not willing to fight for?
Punishment for desertion.: 6/23/2016 04:16:21


Leibstandarte (Vengeance)
Level 40
Report
Total war saves lives. gtfo you pacifists; war encourages innovation.

''I agree, if both world wars didn't happen we still would be living in 1960-70ish kinda world''

EDIT: and that's being optimistic.

Edited 6/23/2016 04:16:49
Punishment for desertion.: 6/23/2016 04:16:28


Nitr01
Level 46
Report
Execution or imprisonment for a very long time. They need to be made an example of. A functional efficient military CANNOT have soldiers deserting. Every man is crucial to the war effort.
Punishment for desertion.: 6/23/2016 04:17:44


Leibstandarte (Vengeance)
Level 40
Report
Why live within a country you're not willing to fight for?

''Agreed, why call yourself french if you won't fight for france? (example)''
Punishment for desertion.: 6/23/2016 04:20:22


GeneralPE
Level 56
Report
Why live within a country you're not willing to fight for?

Cuz dey get all dem FWEE moniez
Punishment for desertion.: 6/23/2016 04:21:45


Radical Traditionalist
Level 30
Report
datz rite mah nicquh.
Punishment for desertion.: 6/23/2016 04:24:35


Leibstandarte (Vengeance)
Level 40
Report
gettin dat welfer maynnnnn
Punishment for desertion.: 6/23/2016 04:25:22


Radical Traditionalist
Level 30
Report
get dem reparashun n shit
Punishment for desertion.: 6/23/2016 04:27:06


GeneralPE
Level 56
Report
WE WAZ KAANGGGZZZZ N SHIET!!
Punishment for desertion.: 6/23/2016 04:32:38


Leibstandarte (Vengeance)
Level 40
Report
I NED TO SMUK SOM CRACK N BON WHAYT GIRLZ MAYN WOHOOOO
Punishment for desertion.: 6/23/2016 04:37:50


Zephyrum 
Level 60
Report
Why live within a country you're not willing to fight for?


Because I can't choose what country I was born in.
Punishment for desertion.: 6/23/2016 04:38:32


GeneralPE
Level 56
Report
Become a rapefugee u goof
Punishment for desertion.: 6/23/2016 04:40:04


Жұқтыру
Level 55
Report
It wasn't justified for America to declare war on Japan for bombing Pearl Harbor?


War with near-genocidal intent, ok, yeah, it's ok to shield yourself, kill the genociders as bloodlessly as possible, but what if you are genociders yourself? But let's look at the ongoing wars.

War in Afghanistan (2001 on): it was unjustified for the Taliban to attack, and fear-war the republic government, but it was unjustified for the government to shield and do draft, as that means the killing of innocent folk to stop, what, some oppression at best that most Afghans upheld to some extent, anyway? Killing is only justifiable if it will be sure to stop other killings, and that's not what was happening. And then America, yeah, it's evidently in the wrong.

War in Iraq: clearly unjustfied for America to attack, they had not even any proof of WMD, that's just an excuse, and some Americans dealt with the Iraqi pretty bad - some war crimes were done, read about it all on WikiLeaks, but the draft or war was not justifiable on the Iraqi side either. And Mashriq is evidently unjustified, and the fight against them is - they are doing genocide and dread killing democide.

War in Syria: justified peaceful rebellion, very unjustified riot watch, but mostly unjustified riots afterwards, unjustified on Kurdestani independence, unjustified on Mashriqi invasion, justified to shield against the Mashiriqi invasion.

West Land War: unjustified on the Islaamists, and justified shielding against.
---
Also, if you like innovation and technology so much, then how about fund the sciences and like organisations more, so that the things invented would be more likely to have a purpose outside of war, and hopefully won't make Earth even easier to wreck.

Because I can't choose what country I was born in.


I'm not willing to fight for any country. I will fight to shield the lives and health those near me, but they wouldn't even be in hazard in the first stead if my government did not capitulate, so it's half my government's blame for it.

Edited 6/23/2016 04:41:58
Punishment for desertion.: 6/23/2016 04:45:17


Radical Traditionalist
Level 30
Report
Then move Zeph.
Punishment for desertion.: 6/23/2016 04:46:32


Radical Traditionalist
Level 30
Report
Ye dem whyte bish b dat gud shit V
Punishment for desertion.: 6/23/2016 04:50:45


Жұқтыру
Level 55
Report


Edited 6/23/2016 04:51:20
Punishment for desertion.: 6/23/2016 12:34:10


Paugers
Level 41
Report
Zeph is afraid of getting his hands dirty and fighting should his nation need him kek
Punishment for desertion.: 6/23/2016 13:12:19

Luna {TJC}
Level 56
Report
+1 Zeph
Zeph is afraid of getting his hands dirty and fighting should his nation need him kek
Name a recent war where your nation (America) 'needs' you
Punishment for desertion.: 6/23/2016 13:17:20


Paugers
Level 41
Report
Notice the key word, should, I would fight if my nation needed me to and just fight for my nation in general.
Punishment for desertion.: 6/23/2016 13:25:08


Von Jewburg
Level 35
Report
I think that 20 years should be good. If your desertion results in endangerment of your unit, then life.
Posts 1 - 30 of 35   1  2  Next >>   

Contact | About WarLight | Play Risk Online | Multiplayer Strategy Game | Challenge Friends, Win Money | Skill Game | Terms of Service