<< Back to Off-topic Forum   Search

Posts 1 - 16 of 16   
The Issue With Satire: 7/29/2016 03:15:02


Genghis 
Level 54
Report
A good book that I'd recommend is Don Quixote. It is about a somewhat stereotypical knight's tale that goes amiss and ends up becoming tragegy/comedy at every turn. But the real twist is that the Knight learns that he is being written about as the story progresses, thus meta-commentary from the knight (who goes by the titular name) as well as the author ensues.

I was watching a video about this on the recent movie Deadpool, which discussed its philosophy (Wisecrack, I believe the channel was) and it described that there is an issue with meta-commentary, intertextuality and satire. Because sooner or later, the meta-commentary will have its own meta-commentary and then it has its own, etc., it becomes a cancerous ad infinitum endless spiral loop majigger.

Not to mention, often times the commentary is satirical in nature or references other literature/art, thus creating intertextuality, which I'd argue is one of the worst things ever. This is because it encourages notice of another work, when in my opinion you should have your full attention grasped onto the current piece you are looking into rather some other, older piece that might be better because it is sold as such and confirmation bias ensues.

As for satire, well, it does nothing, it's just pointing stuff out. At first that may seem useful, but what's the use in pointing out world hunger if you can't do anything to personally stop it? You might come off as hypocritical if you preach about world hunger but don't go on a mission to help poor haitian children, or just local hungry in your area.

Or satire on the idiocy of the world. That's about as subjective and thus as useless as any other satire. Thus, satire is just cancer. Half the time it comes off as pretentious and self-absorbed/heavily opinionated.

Yet when some satire pops up with a pretentious message, with a seemingly abstract theme a lot of people eat it up without realizing they're getting the same schematics from another art with a different message that is half-the-time un-recognized and hypocritical.

Thus is the issue with memes. And an issue with the warlight forums all in general.

This was meta btw
The Issue With Satire: 7/29/2016 03:35:32


Zephyrum
Level 60
Report
Ok. Thanks for letting us know.
The Issue With Satire: 7/29/2016 03:35:36


Ox
Level 58
Report
Ok. Thanks for letting us know.
The Issue With Satire: 7/29/2016 03:36:04


Major General Smedley Butler
Level 51
Report
Ok. Thanks for letting us know.
The Issue With Satire: 7/29/2016 04:55:33


Benjamin628 
Level 60
Report
No. Thanks for letting us ok.
The Issue With Satire: 7/29/2016 05:48:34


Leibstandarte (Vengeance)
Level 45
Report
C-C-C-C-C-C-C-COMBO BREAKER!
The Issue With Satire: 7/29/2016 06:54:05


Жұқтыру
Level 56
Report
C-C-C-C-C-C-C-COMBO BREAKER!
The Issue With Satire: 7/29/2016 07:25:18


Major General Smedley Butler
Level 51
Report
C-C-C-C-C-C-C-COMBO BREAKER!
The Issue With Satire: 7/29/2016 08:42:52


Genghis 
Level 54
Report
This comment chain proves my point.

Memes serve to the detriment of humor and intelligence. You replace individual expression and originality with continuity and repetition, and nothing of value is created and it only intoxicates the value that was there if any.
The Issue With Satire: 7/29/2016 13:08:44


GeneralPE
Level 56
Report
Ok. Thanks for letting us know.
The Issue With Satire: 7/29/2016 13:25:53


Benjamin628 
Level 60
Report
+ 1 to Genghis both posts
The Issue With Satire: 7/29/2016 13:42:12


Anglo
Level 11
Report
+ 1 to Genghis both posts
The Issue With Satire: 7/29/2016 14:40:46


Lolicon love
Level 56
Report
I see.
The Issue With Satire: 7/29/2016 15:08:12


Ox
Level 58
Report
I see.
The Issue With Satire: 7/29/2016 15:10:55


Fan the Apostle
Level 56
Report
Um.ok
The Issue With Satire: 7/29/2016 17:29:22


Roose Bolton
Level 56
Report
( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°) ebin
Posts 1 - 16 of 16