He said he thinks is is overrated; i.e. that he does not consider the map to be as good as it is portrayed by the majority of the community. That means nothing you say can dispute that point.
RoR is acceptable; otherwise Fizzer would not let it into the game. I just consider it to be far inferior to most other maps.
that there are far better maps [than RoR]
Than it isn't a top map.
It's ... a fantastic map
Contradiction? If something is far worse than other maps (which was confirmed by you) than I find it hard to consider it fantastic (also stated by you).