Whether or not this is a good idea or not GeneralGror depends on just only one thing. How the information is relayed in public by silver.

So Silver, please answer us:

How would a Seer investigating a seer in the night look like?

Like this:
A seer scried a seer last night

If that is the case, we could do it, but only if that is the case. And in that case we would have to make absolutely certain that the other seer is 100% investigating me, because if not he would just sign my death sentence.

So once we got information on that by Silver, we can talk about it.

A seer scried another seer!

That's how it would look.

Edited 12/19/2014 13:20:23

Okay, than I have no objection.

I am willing to not vote first day tommorrow, if we all agree on that, under the only condition that by some bad luck our second hero doesnt die this night. (or the other seer of course)

Edited 12/19/2014 13:23:41

VOTE: MYHAND

Oh I meant not witches

Um...Mr. Fall, I realize you have full privilege to do what you want to in this game and I appreciate your earlier defense of me, but if anyone is still unclear on this,

I DO NOT ENDORSE ANY LYNCHING OF MYHAND.

I want him verified, yes, but lynched, no way. There are other good targets.

I don't expect it to ever go through anyways :p

Stupid. You want my hand checked up. How do you propose we be informed of the results?

Mr fall + dr stupid maf confirmed, ez game ez lyfe

mr fall you have no evidence to back your claim except you want to remove the uncountered seer so you can survive as a witch

I am actually just a wee villager, acting for the greater good. The evidence points towards those who try and kill the "seer" (most likely seer, possibly not), without any information. They are poor witches who will lose the game, and we may as well accept their gift

We already covered that on the previous page his balls, the second seer sees myhand tomorrow night (can't tonight b/c myhand can't be seered tonight) and then silver announces a seer has scried a seer.

Okay, I encourage the lynching of Mr.Fall.
Day 1 when Semi exposed himself so brilliantly Mr.Fall said "shrugs, makes sense". But he didnt vote. In fact he delayed his vote while it was still unclear wether me or Semi would take the fall.
Now he comes out voting against me.

I would say lynch him instead of Dr.Stupid.

I have trust in myhand.

I said I'd vote last second in case anyone else came up with a better choice, don't try and turn this around on me. I'm just trying to make logical choices, and Dr. Stupid makes a decent argument. But oh no, I disagreed with the all-powerful Myhand so I must be a witch

get the fuck over yourself -.-

Edited 12/19/2014 22:15:46

I side with myhand.

Instead of trusting and siding with someone be so kind and actually vote. -.-'

Votes:
Dr. Stupid - Arun
Mr. Fall - Myhandisonfire
Myhandisonfire - Arun
Seahawks - Dr. Stupid

Total counts:
Arun - 2
Dr. Stupid - 1
Myhandisonfire - 1

Yet to vote:
Ace Windu
Arun
A Talking Fan
Dom365
GeneralGror
His balls.
Jesuslight
John Smith
Kellen the Conquerer
Little Blue
Mayor Sonnen
Uzumaki Naruto

vote Dr. Stoopid

Instead of trusting and siding with someone be so kind and actually vote. -.-'

Without the ability to change votes, voting early can be a very bad move I think....


@myhand - Have you considered it from our point of view? You've confirmed yourself, and keep acting high and mighty, even though only yourself knows you're a seer (assuming you are, ofc). You surely must realise that it's very difficult in this game to trust anybody wholeheartedly, yet you're expecting all villagers to do so; it could be a witchy plot, or even if you are a seer, it doesn't necessarily mean it's a good idea.

That said, I do not advocate lynching/testing you yet. I'm also thoroughly unconvinced by the plan to seer you tomorrow. What if there was only one hero?


@Dr Stupid - I've seen first-hand that you're a good player. I didn't expect you to try and steal immunity like that. It seems too rash to be a witchy ploy, but it's horrendous village play all the same. Moreover, though, please follow up on your initial Arun accusation. You said "explanations to follow" but, as yet, haven't followed up on them. Please do so.

dom, I explained myself multiple times.
The logic i used is flawless, even i were to be a witch. It is not my fault that many people seem to have problems following it, but it is tiring me out.
Just one day passed, I had an unlucky scry and everybody is running around panicking. How much of this is witchcraft and how much is just villagepsychosis is hard to tell yet.

I explained my logic, I gave out my advice and I painted a roadmap, what the village does with it is up to the individual villager.

I will not justify me any further in the future.