what we should do is go back and think what roles are out their that are not specific/unclaimed.

3 villagers
1 Hunter (appears villager)
1 Tanner
2 Wolves (Although FK claims to be 1)
1 Drunk
1 Minion

We know one villager and one wolf was in the 3 unclaimed cards
We do not know the third card
We know there must be one "Bad card" out so to speak assuming Ace is correct.

However we only know what cards are out there by what the other roles have said.

So we have to presume quite a few things:

1) No claimed roles are lying
2) The drunk was not in play (however I believe he was)
3) That at least one "bad role" is still in the unclaimed cards (I think both wolves are in the unclaimed cards)

So with that I believe we are;

1)looking for a Minion
2)looking for a Drunk, Hunter, Tanner and two villagers

These two sum us up to the 5 villager claims we have had and FK who could be anything.

However this can only be made from the 3 assumptions above.

And basing on that I think:

1) Skunk was the drunk
2)FK is betting on being a villager special
3) Apollo is the Tanner trying to be lynched as a Hunter

Should we not go for Apollo?

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1-Ykyt_FAImHvpuvMFUm3dmhehZlAFRHX3WKG8U0MC_4/edit?usp=docslist_api

We need to check out skunk

I cant prove that Coaleyes is a minion but neither can you prove she isn't.

@Fan The problem is do you want to be responsible for a village win or loss?


Everything is guesswork.

I guess your right . However this the first day. So this is where the most guesses happen. It would get less plausible later on.

Edited 6/21/2015 10:29:19

@Fan no editing

And there is only ONE day

Are you using bribery not to get yourself killed? Yourtalking weird recently

I don't accuse you or anthing , nothing personal

Typo edited

Edited 6/21/2015 10:37:02

I'm just trying to work out if you understand that there is only one day so the game ends at 8pm GMT.


Therefore voting does matter alot.

Yeah...Fan...there is only one day...

Oh ok

Coaleyes. None of the special claims have been countered so I think it's safe to assume they are telling the truth. If not someone who knows different would say so. We have to believe these claims or we wouldn't get anywhere.

Therefore his balls, ace, talking fan, coaleyes, are immediately cleared. Talking fan has cleared ghengis. Traintown is cleared as I swapped him with the cleared talking fan

That leaves Apollo, forbidden knowledge, myhand and skunk could have started as one of:

1 x warewolf (the other was in the spares)
1 x minion
1 x hunter/villager
1 x drunk (may be is afraid they took the known wolf in the spares)
1 x tanner

I say skunk is wolf. fK is tanner or minion.

Myhand and Apollo are hard to pick. One of them is tanner or minion to. I maybe back myhand.

I'm voting skunk.

You've all got this wrong, your being fooled by Coaleyes.

I don't understand why Coaleyes did not say who the troublemaker was and instead waited for his balls' claim.

Coaleyes is a minion

I dunno, I think Coaleyes is telling the truth now. I definitely can't see how Coaleyes and his balls are on the wolf team which I was considering briefly. Skunk, I'm quite suspicious of you right now but I have no read on too many people.

I'm annoyed at FK saying he's a wolf, that play is kind of an FU to the game.

FK makes us question if he is a wolf, tanner, minion or a villager hoping to be a special.

It could be a really good tactic or a really bad play.

Apollo saying he thinks he's the hunter looks bad to me, it means he's taking the claimed villagers at their word even though we know we have too many villagers claimed. He goes after skunk though which is something to consider.

Coaleyes, as a tactic it is an FU to us. You shouldn't ever claim wolf.