There weren't 2 tanners in the distribution.

I regret checking this one last time before going to sleep. But I need to say what I know now before confusion starts.

I believe that General Gror is the troublemaker

I believe that Coaleyes was the tanner, making me the tanner now.

I know I was not a Tanner at the start, I was a seer. Making Coaleyes a seer now.

Genghis is lying. He would not have seen me as a Tanner as the doubleganger's role happens before the troublemaker. I repeat in bold Genghis is lying, it is impossible for him to be the doubleganger and see me as a seer.

This means that Genghis is either a wolf or minion.

BUT last night I seered Forbidden Knowledge. Forbidden Knowledge is a minion. So we do not want to lynch Forbidden Knowledge at all costs.

So as Forbidden Knowledge is the minion Genghis cannot be a minion, he has to be a wolf.

I repeat Genghis is a wolf, I will be voting for him tonight as I have no chance winner as the tanner, I just don't want the wolves to win.

umm how do you know that?

that was to train^

Correction above, I meant for him to see me as a tanner in bold.

but okay well that clears up the tanner business.

I was given tanner. That's all i know.

i think we should consider other factors like the villagers. but for now i agree

Speck, there are 10 players in this game. There are 3 wolves, 2 villagers, and 3 spare roles.

In the distribution, there is (in no particular order):

1 Seer
1 Doppelganger
1 Troublemaker
1 Tanner
1 Minion
1 Drunk
1 Robber
1 Hunter
3 Villagers
2 Werewolves

This makes a total of 13 roles, which, when distributed between 3 spare roles and 10 players, allows no room for duplicate special roles.

well thanks skunk for letting us win.

oh i see now. i thought that there were three roles that were used and then there were multiple of a role.

not used

so for example one villager spot could be a spare role but then there would still be two other villagers. correct?

in the initial roles

Yeah, if it happened to end up like that, there could be 1 villager in a spare role as well as 2 other villagers in play.

Also, at this point I am reasonably certain that I am not on team wolf, so I will reveal what I actually was. I began as the actual drunk, further confirming that FK was lying.

oh then i guess then the villagers work out. one of us is the Hunter. Too bad we won't get to use the ability

so i guess that makes the spare roles Wolf, Doppleganger and Robber.

Possibly even Villager or Hunter instead of Wolf. One of the remaining villagers could still be lying.

true. but you could also be a wolf xD.

which spare role did you pick?

A.