It would be better if you didn't rob me

Hell...I don't know. Pulsey could have acknowledged his role then never came back, and Gror could not have by then? or Pulsey could be a standard villager and Gror could be a Hunter, who actually can have an important role?

I think it's really rather academic though. Either you think he just hasn't been playing and choose to go with one of the other suspicious ones, like me, or you go like you and pick him because he hasn't said anything and you don't think anyone else is better? One way or another it's all still guesswork. And even him popping in and claiming something won't change anything.

I just robbed your identity not your money. And you didn't noticed that I don't see your problem. I did my job, I have to flee the town, I don't want werewolf to eat me.

At least I think vote are yet closed no ?

49 Minutes left.

And as you say Traintown all of that is just guesswork because this topic hasn't been enough active. Look at that : only seven sheets with the two first before the start of the day and a lot a pictures. Pulsey didn't say anything. With all of that we have to make in a way a random choice.

O god imagine the chaos if Pulsey got on and really HAS been doing other things and was the troublemaker?! What a wrench that could throw in the works...

But as I said before that could be normal to a wolf to don't speak much because that could be a way to make people forget you. I agree that strange to don't speak at all

Yeah...and complicating...damn :(

Broken my laptop so sorry for inactivity :( might struggle with my pretty little graphic, too!


40 minutes until deadline!

DOM! Welcome back :D

Luna and Thomas, Who do you suspect and why?

ATF too, you've contributed nothing beyond saying that you're a villager.

I'm not so sure about Luna as the Minion role. They haven't really said anything incriminating that I've noticed and actually did call up Pulsey as being a possible lurker wolf.

Luna, why comment, but don't defend yourself? You're under suspicion of being team wolf, yo!

What I HOPE from the small amount of info we have:
MightySpeck - Seer
Coaleyes - Doppelganger
Gror - Drunk turned villager
ATF - ville/hunter
Glen - Robber turned Ville/hunter
(do we know if the hunter role is revealed to the robber?)
TT - Ville/Hunter
Luna - Ville/hunter
Pulsey - ?
Salty - Ville/hunter
Thomas - Tanner (claims ville)

Spares - Wolf, Troublemaker , villager

If we assume that there were the following roles available:
2 Werewolves
1 Robber
1 Tanner
1 Doppelganger
1 Troublemaker
1 Drunk
1 Seer
1 Minion
1 Hunter
3 Villagers (total of 13 - 10 players + 3 spare)

so even in this optimistic view, there are 5 villager claims and 2 claims that slot C was a villager.
Assuming Glen, Speck and coaleyes are not lying, there are at least two liars in the villager claim. 3 villagers, 1 hunter, 2 liars.

The troublemaker role being spare would be nice as it would complicate things further (and we are thinly spread as is!). It does make sense too, as the TM has no reason to hide his night action. If Pulsey is the TM that'd be a problem though...

So, based on these assumptions, 2 of the following must be guilty:
Pulsey
SirSalty
Traintown
Luna
Thomas
ATF

One must be a werewolf and one must be a minion. If the spare role is the TM then we have a 16.67% likelihood of bagging the wolf on blind guesswork hehe

Likely team wolf:
Thomas

Possibly team wolf:
Sir Salty
Luna
ATF

Unlikely team wolf:
Traintown

No info:
Pulsey

Ughhh!
Come on pulster. Make an effort

Edit: forgot to add my role :P

Edited 1/12/2016 19:44:20

All we know is there is at least one bad person in the bunch.

And if they tanner gets lynched again -_-'

I personally won't be voting Thomas, I never believe someone who says they are a wolf.

Also Dom if we didn't have your story ending it wouldn't be a game of wolves.

Scratch ATF from the suspect list. I don't think Glen is lying.

Well...if nothing else, at least it picked up a bit in the last 2 hours.

Yes, if Pulsey was the troublemaker that could completely change the game.

But I'm still thinking that Thomas is the tanner, he played it badly but after that he just came saying : I was kidding I'm villager. And nothing more. He never tried to justify himself or to proove his innocence. And we have too many villagers.

After that, Luna , I agree, could be a wolf as a minion but I'm more thinking about the minion as he takes risks accusing everyone. And the minion didn't have to be living at the end of the game to win. He just need wolves to survive.

Sir Salty tried to accuse GeneralGror at one moment but that was with the tone of humour so I have no real reasons to suspect him.


And then I remains one people, the one who never spoke, Pulsey. And if he's a wolf that could be a reason to remain silent, a bad reason I agree, not really clever but still a reason.

And I'm pretty sure that if he was really not playing Dom would have asked someone to play at his place as he was going to do with generalgror. So Pulsey may have tell him he was going to remain silent.

So we're down to 50:50 Luna or salty
although nobody knows what Thomas is either, because he's not contributed anything useful

I agree that pulsey probably sent his night action to dom

If he was the troublemaker I'm going to be really annoyed.