On the one hand, if you say one is the Villager and the Drunk (if there was a Drunk) picked that one, he can be sure he's on our side. But if it was the werewolf he picked, then the only thing revealing it would do would confirm what he is for him. He could then just lie and say it was the villager he picked. Heck, he could have picked B too...
Also thought the Drunk could reveal what they picked first, but that is risky for him...
I guess there's not a whole lot of benefit...
One Night Ultimate Werewolf #3: 1/11/2016 18:59:27
I wouldn't see why you would admit to being a drunk.
Role update!!!
A Talking Fan - Villager (now robber) Coaleyes - Doppleganger (now 2nd seer) Claims wolf and villager in middle GeneralGror - ??? Glen - Robber (now villager) MightySpeck - Seer - Claims looked at middle, not comment on what seen New Luna Republic - ??? Pulsey - ??? SirSalty - ??? Thomas 633 - Claims wolf, I doubt very much wolf Traintown - Villager
Middle - Villager - Wolf - ???
Role's in the game
DOPPELGANGER - Claimed WEREWOLF 1 - ??Claimed WEREWOLF 2 - Not in play MINION - SEER - Claimed ROBBER - Claimed 1 card left not in play?? TROUBLEMAKER - DRUNK - HUNTER - TANNER - VILLAGER 1 -Claimed VILLAGER 2 -Claimed VILLAGER 3 -Not in Play
One Night Ultimate Werewolf #3: 1/11/2016 19:31:13
I still don't know what to make about Thomas' Wolf claim. On the one hand, he could be a Tanner, and just very bad at it. On the other hand, he could genuinely be a wolf (who would ever vote for someone who actually CLAIMS to be a Wolf. On the third hand, he could be a smarter Tanner, who wants us to interpret it like that last way. Or, he could be trolling. Or he could be the drunk, and just wants us to ignore him until he figures out what is going on. Or probably other things I haven't thought of.
Help :(
BTW, that 2nd Wolf could still be in play. And that Villager too. If the Drunk took one of them. I plan on doing a post like yours soon, with my thoughts on claims and such.
One Night Ultimate Werewolf #3: 1/11/2016 19:42:33
At the moment, I think that's too difficult to make any theories. We don't have any information about GeneralGror, New Luna Republic, Pulsy and SirSalty.
I don't understand what MightySpeck is doing. If Coaleyes doesn't lie, MightySpeck is the seer, or thinks he is (When the troublemaker switch the role of two players, they don't know they've been switched and their new role). But his behaviour since the beggining of the game is strange. One reason could be that Coaleyes and MightySpeck are both wolves and so they made a plan to try to prove their innocence. But I think that can't be the reason, there are to many risks (with that theory, they have to be sure that the doppleganger is not in game. After that, say that one villager and one wolf are in the spare roles is not so hasardous). But all of that is really unlikely.
Remains the case of Thomas 633 who claims to be a wolf and didn't say any convincing things after that.
Anyway, we need more information to make good theories so those who didn't claim their roles have to do it soon, because tomorrow at 8PM we will have to lynch someone and for now, that's just impossible to choose a suspect. That's like tossing a coin !
One Night Ultimate Werewolf #3: 1/11/2016 21:24:06
Also i misread my mod info so i agree with coal. A is wolf and c is villager.
A Talking Fan - Villager (now robber) Coaleyes - Doppleganger (now 2nd seer) Claims wolf and villager in middle GeneralGror - Drunk (now spare C) Glen - Robber (now villager) MightySpeck - Seer - Claims looked at middle, A is wolf,C is villager New Luna Republic - Villager Pulsey - ??? SirSalty - ??? Thomas 633 - Claims wolf, I doubt very much wolf Traintown - Villager
Middle - Villager - Wolf - ???
Role's in the game
DOPPELGANGER - Claimed WEREWOLF 1 - ??Claimed WEREWOLF 2 - Not in play MINION - SEER - Claimed ROBBER - Claimed 1 card left not in play?? TROUBLEMAKER - DRUNK -GeneralGror HUNTER - TANNER - VILLAGER 1 -Claimed VILLAGER 2 -Claimed VILLAGER 3 -Not in Play
