Play
Multi-Player
Coins
Community
Settings
Help
Community   Maps   Forum   Mail   Ladders   Clans   Recent Games
Sign In | Sign Up
<< Back to Off-topic Forum   

Posts 1 - 30 of 60   1  2  Next >>   
Jews: Should they be legal?: 2/3/2016 16:12:23


[WL] Colonel Harthacanute
Level 50
Report
I mean, should race as a whole be legal?

Before you shrug this thread off, consider what I'm saying:

Race was the driving force behind the biggest genocide known in history. Race is the driving force behind the only surviving system of apartheid in the 21st Century. Should race just be banned altogether?



Your thought, gentlemen, would be much appreciated. Thanks.
Jews: Should they be legal?: 2/3/2016 16:17:48


[EIC] Cade
Level 45
Report
You are dumb
Jews: Should they be legal?: 2/3/2016 16:22:00


Azraelkali53
Level 46
Report
race is a reality it can't be outlawed. its as if you're saying gravity should it be legal?
Jews: Should they be legal?: 2/3/2016 16:22:00


Azraelkali53
Level 46
Report
race is a reality it can't be outlawed. its as if you're saying gravity should it be legal?
Jews: Should they be legal?: 2/3/2016 16:23:41


Death 
Level 59
Report
How does one ban race?
Jews: Should they be legal?: 2/3/2016 16:24:49


GeneralPE
Level 56
Report
Give everyone melanin transplants so we are all black. That or genocide all races but 1. You choose.

"the only surviving system of apartheid in the 21st Century"
Which country is still apartheid?

Edited 2/3/2016 16:35:47
Jews: Should they be legal?: 2/3/2016 16:25:00


King C******* V
Level 58
Report
You cant ban race at a international or domestic scale.
Jews: Should they be legal?: 2/3/2016 16:28:41


(((Tabby Juggernaut)))
Level 50
Report
Race is not a reality, at least not genetically: people supposedly of the same race/ethnicity has a diversity on Y-chromosome DNA, mitochondrial DNA, etc. For example Serbs are certainly not black Africans, but a sizeable minority of Serbs have the same Y-chromosome haplogroup (E) as many Bantu Africans. So yes race will disappear. The current perception of race is just a non-well-defined concept.

Edited 2/3/2016 16:30:07
Jews: Should they be legal?: 2/3/2016 16:35:02


GeneralPE
Level 56
Report
Because, ya know, COLOR isn't at all a dividing force.
Jews: Should they be legal?: 2/3/2016 16:40:22


DesertFox
Level 56
Report
that image is insulting and the idea is shity
(my hoonest thoughts )
A wall...to stop us...LOL
Jews: Should they be legal?: 2/3/2016 16:41:50


(((Tabby Juggernaut)))
Level 50
Report
Yes racism is just a temporary thing..ancient people did not care about it..nor will future people.

If Jews are a race, then I assume Christians and Muslims are races too. Is that correct?
Jews: Should they be legal?: 2/3/2016 16:44:35


GeneralPE
Level 56
Report
No, because Muslims and Christians aren't a Semitic people originating in Palestine with distinct physical characteristics. You are actually so stupid to draw that parallel

BTW that image is fake. He never wanted a wall to keep out Romanians

Edited 2/3/2016 16:46:04
Jews: Should they be legal?: 2/3/2016 16:51:18


(((Tabby Juggernaut)))
Level 50
Report
@GeneralPE The issue is the same. You can become Jewish through conversion despite the fact that conversions are discouraged and are rare. You can not become Kurdish for example through "conversion". You can not become an ethnic Russian or German, either.

Jews supposedly have distinct physical characteristics...What about Beta Israel and Kaifeng Jews? Even Ashkenazis and Sephardi Jews don't always look the same. I have been around many (generally wonderful) Jewish people.. some look European..some does look distinct..some are black (Ethiopian Jewry)

The correct term should be...an ethno-religious group. Jews are partly (and in reality largely) hereditary but not fully so, hence not a race.

Edited 2/3/2016 16:53:09
Jews: Should they be legal?: 2/3/2016 16:56:51


Darth Darth Binks
Level 56
Report
@GeneralPE The issue is the same. You can become Jewish through conversion despite the fact that conversions are discouraged and are rare. You can not become Kurdish for example through "conversion". You can not become an ethnic Russian or German, either.

You can follow Judaism. You cannot become a Jew.

Edited 2/3/2016 16:56:59
Jews: Should they be legal?: 2/3/2016 16:57:08


Azraelkali53
Level 46
Report
Tabby you dont know shit. Ashkenazi jews and khazars are two examples of a distinct race. Indeed Binks. Judaism is the religions jews are the race.

Edited 2/3/2016 16:59:12
Jews: Should they be legal?: 2/3/2016 17:16:44


(((Tabby Juggernaut)))
Level 50
Report
@Hell's Gas Station:

OK Rabbinical Judaism defines a Jew as someone whose mother is a Jew or someone that converts to Judaism. Karaite Judaism defines a Jew as someone whose father is a Jew or someone that converts to Judaism. Hence at least according to Judaism Jewishness is not entirely hereditary.

Please explain to me what the Jewish race is....if you exclude a lot of people who identify as Jews from being Jews. Do you believe that only Sephardi Jews are actually Jews? Or you want to say...you can not be Jewish unless you have Y-chromosome halogroup J1 for example? But most Jews are not actually J1 so?

@Darth Darth Binks You should ask Chabad-Lubavitch or Breslov whether it is possible for a non-Jew to become a Jew (hard but certainly possible)

Edited 2/3/2016 17:20:07
Jews: Should they be legal?: 2/3/2016 17:19:52


Azraelkali53
Level 46
Report
science has already defined it. Its not my job. google it.
Jews: Should they be legal?: 2/3/2016 17:21:35


(((Tabby Juggernaut)))
Level 50
Report
@HGS I know most Jewish Kohens are of Y-chromosome haplogroup J1. BTW science has not defined what the Jewish race is supposed to be..just what typical genes of Jews, Levites and Kohens are.

Edited 2/3/2016 17:21:46
Jews: Should they be legal?: 2/3/2016 17:25:18


Azraelkali53
Level 46
Report
It has defined ashkenazim which are the majority. Ashkenazim are typically italian/semite hybrids.
Jews: Should they be legal?: 2/3/2016 17:38:24


(((Tabby Juggernaut)))
Level 50
Report
@HGS The issue is we need to clarify what the term "Jew" means: Who is Jewish? Unlike "American", which is just citizenship which is easy to check, a lot of terms are hard to define. For example who is an African American? We don't include Afrikaaner Americans, don't we? An Asian American can not be an ethnic Russian that was born in Russian Asia.. Caucasian Americans do not only include people that have ancestors in the Caucasus. Native Americans do not include everybody that was born either in Americas or in the United States of America. What does "Chinese" or "German" even mean? Citizenship? Ethnic group? Are Uyghurs largely Chinese? Are American citizens born in China Chinese? Are Austrians largely German? Can someone be German if he/she is actually ethnic Danish? The word "Jewish" is also hard to determine.

Edited 2/3/2016 17:40:52
Jews: Should they be legal?: 2/3/2016 17:53:53


Azraelkali53
Level 46
Report
no its not hard to define at all. Jew is an ethnic group just like german, dutch, irish and scottish. Only people who are genetically jewish are jews. Its that simple take your marxist mind games to tumblr.
Jews: Should they be legal?: 2/3/2016 17:57:57


(((Tabby Juggernaut)))
Level 50
Report
I'm not a Marxist..where does that idea even come from meow?
Furthermore I don't even have a tumblr account! What are you talking about, may I ask?

Ad hominem is not legitimate rational thinking.

Edited 2/3/2016 17:59:50
Jews: Should they be legal?: 2/3/2016 17:59:43


Azraelkali53
Level 46
Report
nice try commie you can't fool me. God bless these united states and the liberal principles upon which they were founded.

Edited 2/3/2016 18:00:44
Jews: Should they be legal?: 2/3/2016 18:01:27


(((Tabby Juggernaut)))
Level 50
Report
@HGS LOL I'm not a Commie. I actually used to be pretty right-wing. Now a complete individualist anti-collectivist against any form of sexuality and other conformist behaviors, including ethnicitism. So anything but communist since communism requires collectivism.

I live in Ameowrica. It is good.

I hate any form of collectivism. Humans should live free from collectivism like cats.

Edited 2/3/2016 18:07:09
Jews: Should they be legal?: 2/3/2016 18:07:13


Azraelkali53
Level 46
Report
Nice try commie. Nice try.
Jews: Should they be legal?: 2/3/2016 18:13:50


(((Tabby Juggernaut)))
Level 50
Report
LOL Have I ever advocated for anything Communist? Instead I advocate usually for individualism: The individual is always independent of the society. Individual responsibility requires individual freedom from social coercion. Hence individuals should largely not be born into identities, they should acquire identities by merit, not by birth. Generally things about the individual should never come from ancestry.

Edited 2/3/2016 18:16:00
Jews: Should they be legal?: 2/3/2016 18:49:45


[WOLF] The Conservative
Level 56
Report
Gas station is just a troll pay no attention to him, nobody else does
Jews: Should they be legal?: 2/3/2016 19:16:20


DesertFox
Level 56
Report
but have you observed that, even if the tile of the forum is about Jews, the first image is about my people ?
Jews: Should they be legal?: 2/3/2016 20:11:15


DomCobb
Level 45
Report
Good thing he is no longer part of the Royal Falcons.
Jews: Should they be legal?: 2/3/2016 20:34:30


Death 
Level 59
Report
Threads by Colonel in a nutshell - After seeing the last one, you'd think there couldn't be any worse than that. Well, you were wrong.
Posts 1 - 30 of 60   1  2  Next >>   

Contact | About WarLight | Play Risk Online | Multiplayer Strategy Game | Challenge Friends, Win Money | Skill Game | Terms of Service