Play
Multi-Player
Coins
Community
Settings
Help
Community   Maps   Forum   Mail   Tournaments   Ladders   Clans   Recent Games
Sign In | Sign Up
<< Back to Off-topic Forum   

Posts 1 - 25 of 25   
*REMADE* What If? Part 1: Facist Poland: 7/12/2016 01:24:55


Nobody
Level 43
Report
Hello Amigos! Today I Will Make The (Probably) First ``What If´´ Discussion!
So,In This Timeline... WW1 Was A Stalemate
Neither Saide Could Get The Win.
After 6 Years Of War 1914-1920,They Made White Peace.
And One Of The Articules Said That Poland Would Get It´s Independence.
And Poland Was Fully Recgonized In 1925.
Hitler Was One Of The German Soldiers That Dies On Battle Of Verdun.

Well,That Is All The Information I Can Give You.
One MoreThing: Poland Is In A Battle With Czechslovakia (New Country Created By Rebels) Because There Is Border Agiung.

New Countries:
Poland --- Lithuania --- Finnish-Estonian Commonwealth --- Latvia --- Czechslovakia --- Bavaria --- USSR --- Napoli ---- And Ukrania.

(I Know This Is KINDA Stupid,But Just Get Along With it.)
-Nobody (Nobody Here)
*REMADE* What If? Part 1: Facist Poland: 7/12/2016 01:54:04


Major General Smedley Butler
Level 51
Report
Poland was fascist.
*REMADE* What If? Part 1: Facist Poland: 7/12/2016 14:06:11


Riveath
Level 59
Report
To an extent, yes. Piłsudski did install a dictatorship. I don't know that much about it, so I won't make arguments to support the idea of Poland not being fascist, but hey, it still got invaded by the Nazis, didn't it? :p
*REMADE* What If? Part 1: Facist Poland: 7/12/2016 14:10:32


Leibstandarte (Vengeance)
Level 45
Report
It doesn't matter if Poland was fascist,dictatorship,republic,monarchy,communist. It WOULD get SMASHED by USSR and Germany.
*REMADE* What If? Part 1: Facist Poland: 7/12/2016 16:55:14


Riveath
Level 59
Report
^ can't deny that, lol.

If Germany and USSR decided to gangbang Poland (which they did), Poland's ideology does not matter at all.
*REMADE* What If? Part 1: Facist Poland: 7/12/2016 17:26:03


Major General Smedley Butler
Level 51
Report
Well from what I see, you could probably make the distinction between it and fascism and just call it a junta (military government) but Hitler did admire Piłsudski.
*REMADE* What If? Part 1: Facist Poland: 7/12/2016 18:36:48


DomCobb
Level 46
Report
>White Peace
>Sides make demands of each other

Sounds like you don't know what a white peace is...
*REMADE* What If? Part 1: Facist Poland: 7/12/2016 22:07:32


Major General Smedley Butler
Level 51
Report
It doesn't matter if Poland was fascist,dictatorship,republic,monarchy,communist. It WOULD get SMASHED by USSR and Germany.

Poland had already been awfully smashed by Germany for a month before the Soviets occupied Eastern Portions of it. And if it had been, say, allied to Czechoslovakia and prevented Czechoslovakia from being annexed puppeted by Germany, it isn't a stretch to say Poland, Czechoslovakia and Romania couldn't beat Germany in a war, considering the best German tanks by the time Germany engaged in war with Poland were Czech made, and the Sudentanland was defended by a line comparable to the Maginot line. Especially with French and Soviet support if the pact manages to hold.
*REMADE* What If? Part 1: Facist Poland: 7/13/2016 22:03:22


Жұқтыру
Level 55
Report
Not sure if Piłsudski can be called fascist. He was very much authoritarian, and bit of the fascist block, made deals with Germany, planned for a joint invasion of Russia with Germany, giving full military access, but eventually relations soured when Poland refused to give the Gdansk hallway.
*REMADE* What If? Part 1: Facist Poland: 7/13/2016 23:21:04


Major General Smedley Butler
Level 51
Report
Hitler said he didn't really care about the corridor and just wanted Poland itself.
*REMADE* What If? Part 1: Facist Poland: 7/14/2016 02:12:25


Major General Smedley Butler
Level 51
Report
With minor exceptions German national unification has been achieved. Further successes cannot be achieved without bloodshed. Poland will always be on the side of our adversaries... Danzig is not the objective. It is a matter of expanding our living space in the east, of making our food supply secure, and solving the problem of the Baltic states. To provide sufficient food you must have sparsely settled areas. There is therefore no question of sparing Poland, and the decision remains to attack Poland at the first opportunity. We cannot expect a repetition of Czechoslovakia. There will be fighting.
- Hitler, May of 1939 while addressing German Generals.
*REMADE* What If? Part 1: Facist Poland: 7/14/2016 19:16:47


Major General Smedley Butler
Level 51
Report
Comes from Kursk: The Greatest Battle: Eastern Front 1943 on page 26.

And no, you cannot claim everything that opposes your worldview a forgery.
*REMADE* What If? Part 1: Facist Poland: 7/14/2016 21:06:12


Major General Smedley Butler
Level 51
Report
Most lorewriters consider that book a falsehood maker, and yes I have, I have shown where it is from, go to that book for more, anyway, you and X are wrong.
*REMADE* What If? Part 1: Facist Poland: 7/14/2016 21:45:22


Izazovnog
Level 45
Report
This thread was not made to be a debate. Rather, it was supposed to a fun topic for the imagination to wander around.

There's absolutely no point taking it literally though. Of course the scenario makes no sense. That's why it didn't happen! Events revolve more around the balance of everything, rather than it does probabilities. There are of course exceptions to this, but that's not the point.

Let's now just take it at a chill, grab a few jelly beans from the jar and throw them out. Just don't spill it. :)

Edited 7/14/2016 21:47:19
*REMADE* What If? Part 1: Facist Poland: 7/14/2016 23:24:47


Major General Smedley Butler
Level 51
Report
Citation: a quotation from or reference to a book, paper, or author, especially in a scholarly work.
*REMADE* What If? Part 1: Facist Poland: 7/14/2016 23:40:34


Major General Smedley Butler
Level 51
Report
Lloyd Clark is a senior academic in the Department of War Studies at the Royal Military Academy Sandhurst and Professorial Research Fellow in War Studies, Humanities Research Institute, University of Buckingham.

You're really grasping at straws Lawlz :)
*REMADE* What If? Part 1: Facist Poland: 7/14/2016 23:48:41


Major General Smedley Butler
Level 51
Report
Give me a real reason why this isn't a citation considering the person who wrote it is educated and generally respected, Lawlz.

Note: Claim to authority argument isn't always a fallacy, and about half the time is considered a valid argument.

Edited 7/14/2016 23:50:54
*REMADE* What If? Part 1: Facist Poland: 7/14/2016 23:50:09


Riveath
Level 59
Report
>Lawlz
>generally respected
*REMADE* What If? Part 1: Facist Poland: 7/14/2016 23:51:44


Major General Smedley Butler
Level 51
Report
>Lawlz
>generally respected


Wasn't calling Lawlz generally respected, I was calling Karl Lawlz.
*REMADE* What If? Part 1: Facist Poland: 7/15/2016 00:09:04


Major General Smedley Butler
Level 51
Report
It is a citation, the definition fits it and the person is an expert in the field. Applying your logic to everything means that there is no validity in any major non fiction media, and if there is validity in non fiction media it means your logic is faulty. Let's see: The newscaster said it would be around 100 degrees F today, and what do you know, it is.

Your logic and argument is faulty.
*REMADE* What If? Part 1: Facist Poland: 7/15/2016 00:09:53


Major General Smedley Butler
Level 51
Report
Historically, opinion on the appeal to authority has been divided - it has been held to be a valid argument about as often as it has been considered an outright fallacy
*REMADE* What If? Part 1: Facist Poland: 7/15/2016 00:11:03


OxTheAutist 
Level 58
Report
facism sux

fascism on the other hand...
*REMADE* What If? Part 1: Facist Poland: 7/15/2016 12:51:03

Destroyer
Level 41
Report
This is what will happen to Poland
https://www.warlight.net/SinglePlayer/Level?ID=897691
*REMADE* What If? Part 1: Facist Poland: 7/15/2016 12:59:26

c4ooo
Level 42
Report
His quote is very well a citation, @British Fascist i would like *you* to provide a *citation* to prove that his citation is not accurate.
*REMADE* What If? Part 1: Facist Poland: 7/15/2016 13:01:24


Leibstandarte (Vengeance)
Level 45
Report
I'm a decent person.

Edited 7/15/2016 13:02:13
Posts 1 - 25 of 25   

Contact | About WarLight | Play Risk Online | Multiplayer Strategy Game | Skill Game | Terms of Service