<< Back to Off-topic Forum   Search

Posts 11 - 30 of 30   <<Prev   1  2  
There is no secular basis of human rights: 8/5/2017 17:09:58


(deleted)
Level 56
Report
^ I agree. Just replace "pursuit of happiness" with "property".
There is no secular basis of human rights: 8/5/2017 17:30:08


[REGL] Pooh 
Level 62
Report
I disagree with your proposed exchange.

I see pursuit of happiness as an end state, with several routes to be happy (with acquiring property as one means.)

A right to property is too narrow, and for some people, would not result in happiness. There are plenty of happy people, both rich and poor.

To pretend that government knows what is best for all (narrowly defining the right to happiness as a right to property) and to enact laws only to that interpretation wouldn't be right, in my opinion.
There is no secular basis of human rights: 8/5/2017 17:31:45


[REGL] Pooh 
Level 62
Report
There's also plenty of miserable poor and stupid people pursuing happiness by sh*t-posting on internet forums.

Who am I to tell them to stop?
There is no secular basis of human rights: 8/5/2017 17:46:33


Genghis 
Level 54
Report
Why do you guys perpetually circle jerk. Can't you do that on reddit or some shit. I for one want to be able to use off topic again one of these days
There is no secular basis of human rights: 8/5/2017 18:19:41


[REGL] Pooh 
Level 62
Report
Should we get off your lawn too?
There is no secular basis of human rights: 8/5/2017 20:14:56


Cata Cauda
Level 59
Report
^What is the percentage of black farmers who refuse to store food? What about Ashkenazis? For example maybe 1% of South Koreans do not store food. However in DR Congo maybe 99% of the population do not store food. That can be a huge difference.
Where do you get those numbers from? However actually you are rigth maybe. Many people in Congo cant store their food, because they have to sell it to the greedy western world to survive. Afterall we need our 99 cents coffee, right?
There is no secular basis of human rights: 8/5/2017 20:20:14


Cata Cauda
Level 59
Report
I would also like to point our that almost everyone is Congo has no fridge, so due to the hot and wet climate everything that isnt canned or otherwise conserved has to be eaten within 1-2 days.
On the other hand we have South Korea, with a more temperate climate, and almost everyone having a fridge to store the food for week/months. They also have more conserved food.
There is no secular basis of human rights: 8/5/2017 20:26:00


Leibstandarte (Vengeance)
Level 45
Report
^ This! I thank you for explaining this.
There is no secular basis of human rights: 8/5/2017 22:20:00


apollong3
Level 53
Report
Human rights are social constructs created by religion, specifically Judeo-Christian values.


So you are one of those people who believe everyone would steal, murder, rape etc if they didn't believe in some kind of god? This is bogus in my opinion.
I won't do horrible things. That's not because I think there is a magical sky daddy watching over my every move, waiting to put me through eternal torment for what I've done.

What's your reason for believing rights to life, liberty and (oh so important) property require religion to be agreed upon?
There is no secular basis of human rights: 8/6/2017 00:03:08


(deleted)
Level 56
Report
Why beat around the bush? Challenge my assertion. Provide a secular basis for human rights.

"Habe Mut, dich deines eigenen Verstandes zu bedienen." or

"Have the courage to use your own reason."
There is no secular basis of human rights: 8/6/2017 08:53:48


apollong3
Level 53
Report
Why beat around the bush? Challenge my assertion. Provide a secular basis for human rights.

*sigh*

Human rights are, as you said, social constructs. They are created by the society to fit their needs and values. No god is needed for that.

What exactly are you asking for? Want me to make my own moral system? I don't need to, plenty have done that before me.

Now, imagine this: It may be hard for you, but for the pusrposes of this thought experiment, think of a world with NO magical sky daddy. Somewhere on earth, at some point, some people have gathered to write a bunch of rules for their society. They sign as "the one true magical sky daddy". However, we both know there is no magical sky daddy in this world. Where did they find those rules? Did they pull them out of their ass? No, they set them according to their society's needs and values.
"But there IS a magical sky daddy"
Sure, but these guys are not the only ones making rules. All over the world there have been numerous religions. Do you think their magical sky daddy exists as well? Of course not, because you think yours is the only one. Where did all the others find the rules to govern their societies?

My argument is this:
Just as well as some people can write some rules (an agreement) and pretend they were given to them by some god, some people can write those rules without pretending to be on behalf of any god. The "one true magical sky daddy" signature would just be gone, not the rules themselves.

Challenge my argument. Prove to me that society needs a god to have human rights.
There is no secular basis of human rights: 8/6/2017 20:55:28


(deleted)
Level 56
Report
Hmm. Those are both good secular arguments for human rights.
There is no secular basis of human rights: 8/7/2017 00:50:54


OnlyThePie
Level 54
Report
points to apollong for being radical
There is no secular basis of human rights: 8/7/2017 12:01:21


apollong3
Level 53
Report
radical?

I didn't even deny the existence of a god
There is no secular basis of human rights: 8/7/2017 12:36:43


Cata Cauda
Level 59
Report
That's sad.
There is no secular basis of human rights: 8/7/2017 14:27:22


OnlyThePie
Level 54
Report
Bro I meant radical like it was used in the 80s. Gnarly, Tubular, Fantastic.
There is no secular basis of human rights: 8/7/2017 15:17:11


apollong3
Level 53
Report
Oh. ._.

I feel like Tabby now
There is no secular basis of human rights: 8/8/2017 03:16:35


Cata Cauda
Level 59
Report
Compared to Tabby we are all Centrists.
There is no secular basis of human rights: 8/8/2017 07:19:46


{Canidae} Kretoma 
Level 59
Report
No they are normal. Americans are just way too capitalist friendly.
There is no secular basis of human rights: 8/8/2017 07:40:26


Cata Cauda
Level 59
Report
^Really? Why?

You are all a bunch of far left people.
And you are ... I don't actually what you are. I would place you in the authoritarian rigth wing.
Posts 11 - 30 of 30   <<Prev   1  2