<< Back to Map Development Forum   Search

Posts 41 - 60 of 87   <<Prev   1  2  3  4  5  Next >>   
A Huge Map for the Earth【World Precision】: 8/28/2012 18:37:00


Issander
Level 55
Report
As the first thing I have to say that my comment will obviously not be objective, as we doing so similar maps.

Then I can give you some advice, that was given to me by Fizzer in the other thread. Use SVG file optimizer. The newer versions of inkscape have one built in. Just 'save as', then change the file extention to 'optimized .SVG file' and that should do. In my case the file size dropped by 25.2%, that should be helpful enough.

The other advice is a bit late, but you should name the territories while making them. Now you have 2000 territories to name, and I can't even imagine how boring it will be for you to name them all! Also, if you want to name them properly, instead of just something like 'Nigeria 1', 'Nigeria 2', 'Nigeria 3'... then you will have to redo a lot of work, cause you will have to find proper divisions in the web again.

The next points could be threated as another advices, but if you considered them, then your map would look just like mine, so it's just some blabbering about why do I think my map is better ;) (Also an attempt to defend my creation from those comparing the maps in this thread :P)

- You're using the same color for all of the small bonuses inside bigger one. If you used similar shades of said color, then it would be looking much more clear.

- You were drawing each territory instead of dividing the paths (--> wiki). That makes them look quite bad in close view. Take a closer look on Burkina Faso on both maps and you'll see what I mean.

- You've used Mercator Projection, while I've chosen Aitoff Projection. Of course both of them have drawbacks, but Aitoff's has less. Just look at Greenland on your map, it's the size of Africa! But that's only aesthetical. You've also ended up with very small territories in the southern part of the map, and very big ones in the northern part, which is the most important drawback of using Aitoff Projection.

- On your map you can cross an Ocean in 2 moves, which make it looks like it was no barrier at all :)
A Huge Map for the Earth【World Precision】: 8/28/2012 18:55:22


Issander
Level 55
Report
There should be 'which is the most important drawback of using Mercator Projection.'

Also, I don't mean that your map is bad or anything like that. You did great, not so many people can do so much work just to create a big map :)
A Huge Map for the Earth【World Precision】: 8/28/2012 20:41:04


Moros 
Level 50
Report
I think now with 2/3rd of the map done it's to late to change the projection... You can't simply reshape the map like that. The same counts for the bonus borders. I must say they look pretty good for hand-work.
And the part about crossing the ocean in two moves: it's still more than on most earth maps, where you cross it in 1 or zero moves. (that means they are connected through a yellow line, without any islands)
I do agree on the bonus colouring part.
A Huge Map for the Earth【World Precision】: 8/28/2012 23:10:30

Caio Veloso
Level 3
Report
you forgot to include Amapa in Brazil.
A Huge Map for the Earth【World Precision】: 8/30/2012 01:01:04


Nyan
Level 55
Report
Personally I love the Mercator projection, it doesn't make the (excuse me) more 'important' countries look like ellipses >.>
A Huge Map for the Earth【World Precision】: 8/30/2012 04:02:32

Sunny Rain
Level 41
Report
Well, the North is huge and the South is (relatively) small.

I'd like to test/ play on the map please send an invite!
A Huge Map for the Earth【World Precision】: 8/30/2012 07:08:46


Issander
Level 55
Report
Which countries are "more important"? :D That's funny concept.
A Huge Map for the Earth【World Precision】: 8/30/2012 11:02:09


hedja 
Level 61
Report
great map, and really good work so far, a lot of effort left to write all the territorie's names
A Huge Map for the Earth【World Precision】: 8/30/2012 13:20:59


Ⓖ. Ⓐrun 
Level 57
Report
if you want help with naming territories, i can help if needed
A Huge Map for the Earth【World Precision】: 8/30/2012 14:06:39


Ironheart
Level 54
Report
i can test both earth if needed
A Huge Map for the Earth【World Precision】: 8/30/2012 18:32:24


Issander
Level 55
Report
A Huge Map for the Earth【World Precision】: 9/2/2012 22:03:41


Issander
Level 55
Report
It seems that my map will be bigger, unless you would add 170+ territories with Antarctica
A Huge Map for the Earth【World Precision】: 9/3/2012 13:03:30


Ⓖ. Ⓐrun 
Level 57
Report
this is definately going to be my favourite earth map :D
A Huge Map for the Earth【World Precision】: 9/4/2012 10:29:16

wigibob
Level 3
Report
your going to enjoy naming all the teritories aren't you *evil laugh*

but seriously that will get boring you should have done it while creating the map

apart from that I think you have done well and it's a good map
A Huge Map for the Earth【World Precision】: 10/16/2012 11:16:42


御坂一二三笠 (dyemen)
Level 11
Report
Now i will continue to complete this map,sorry for stop in this month
A Huge Map for the Earth【World Precision】: 10/16/2012 20:10:33


Min34 
Level 63
Report
You should make the bonussquares for the countries bigger than the bonussquares for parts of the country. For example: The Unitedstates>insert state name< bonussquares are as big as the UnitedStatesofAmerica bonussquare. I would make the last one bigger.
A Huge Map for the Earth【World Precision】: 10/17/2012 03:36:48

AI
Level 2
Report
good job! can't wait to play it with all my friends
A Huge Map for the Earth【World Precision】: 10/17/2012 18:17:47


Ⓖ. Ⓐrun 
Level 57
Report
Will you get booted? :P
A Huge Map for the Earth【World Precision】: 11/10/2012 22:07:30


Art Vandelay
Level 54
Report
A Huge Map for the Earth【World Precision】: 11/11/2012 15:09:59


Ⓖ. Ⓐrun 
Level 57
Report
If you want territory naming help, I'm here :)
Posts 41 - 60 of 87   <<Prev   1  2  3  4  5  Next >>